A tale of two experiences…

January 22, 2010 · 6 comments

Over the years on this blog, I have certainly made no secret of my love for Morton’s. I repeatedly mention I find it hard to beat their incredible combination of friendly servers, terrific menu selection, and excellent food.

However, one night this past week as I was traveling on business, my family and I had two wildly different experiences at two different Morton’s. It’s a great example to all of us in business that how we treat customers at one location impacts our business everywhere else.

While Tammy and Faron were here at home in Indianapolis, I was on the road in Orlando. Tammy was greeted at the door of the local Morton’s, welcomed like an old friend, and Faron was made to feel like the “man of the evening” — even though he’s 15 years old.

(It was a big night for him. Anytime a young man who is a freshman in high school dons a suit and tie and takes his mother out for a elegant dinner, it’s probably going to be an evening he will remember for a long time! Tammy was extraordinarily impressed that the team at Morton’s in Indianapolis made a point to make it a special evening for BOTH of them!)

On the other hand, there was no one at the front when I entered the Orlando Morton’s. Finally when I was approached, I simply mentioned I was alone and would prefer to eat at the bar. Taking my seat, I was given a menu and placed my order for the special at Morton’s is currently running — a combination of filet mignon and lobster tail.

Perhaps it’s because I am the son of a butcher, I have always preferred my steaks done medium-well. However, I hate spending the money it takes to purchase a filet, only to find they have sliced such a great cut of steak in half. I always tell them not to “butterfly” the steak. I understand it will take longer to prepare…however I do not want to rush an extraordinary meal.

When my meal was delivered, the steak was medium-rare. I requested they return it to the grill. When the manager came over, I mentioned that I happen to know many of his colleagues that are managers of Morton’s — as I was the keynote speaker for their annual general manager’s conference a couple of years ago. I even mentioned that I am a great admirer of their management team in Chicago. The manager dismissed that information and told me he had not attended that meeting, as his first conference was just this last year. He put my steak on a plate and took it back to the kitchen.

There seems to me to be a problem with handling it in that manner. If you eat your lobster and vegetables, you have finished most of your meal by the time the steak arrives. If you wait on your steak to be returned, by then the other portions of your meal are cold.

A waiter brought my steak back several minutes later, and did not wait to see if this time it had been properly prepared. Only the waitress behind the bar offered any kind of meager apology — and I never saw the manager again, nor was given his name throughout the entire process. He never shook my hand or thanked me for my patience…or my business. He just disappeared.

After finishing my meal, the waitress offered to provide me a complementary after-dinner drink. Interestingly, she did not mention whether it was because the meal had not been delivered to their customary standards, or if it was just her way of saying “thanks” for someone purchasing a higher priced meal, and two nice glasses of wine while sitting at her bar.

I finished my Bailey’s, signed the check, and stood to go. Not one person said “thank you” or asked if I was satisfied with my experience of the evening.

However — back in Indianapolis — when Tammy finished her meal, she and Faron were asked by both the waiter and the manager on duty if they were pleased, and if there was anything else they could do to ensure their total satisfaction.

Imagine what my phone conversation with my wife was like that evening. She was ecstatic about the dinner she had shared with her son — and I was highly disappointed by the evening I experienced — even though we had both dined at the very same restaurant chain.

Customers do not want you to “make it right.” We want you to GET it right!

If you don’t get it right…we want to know — beyond any doubt — that it matters to you that the experience was soiled. Only when we believe you CARE will your efforts at recovery have any traction.

Consider this: What if my Orlando experience would have been my first trip to Morton’s? I would probably not dine at the one in Indianapolis. However, because of the MANY superior experiences that I’ve had at Morton’s from Indianapolis to Manhattan, from San Francisco to Miami, there’s no doubt I will return.

What’s most important, though, is that every business must realize that each customer counts. Every customer has to be treated as if each visit to your location will determine not only that individual customer’s future expenditures, but the very viability of your enterprise.

If you fail to receive an “ultimate customer experience” the first time… why would you seek to inflict more pain upon yourself with a second trip?

Are you and your team doing everything you can to get it right for your customers?

  • Jim Moran

    Scott-

    Will you go back to the Morton’s in Orlando? Your story also points out that the staff follows the lead of the manager. I’m sure Morton’s has training in place for all of it’s employees and tries to replicate the outstanding service you receive in Indianapolis at their other locations. The Orlando manager has lead his staff astray of the Morton’s standard. Employees will follow a bad leader as well as a great one.

    Love your stories and examples of UCE!

  • Brad Plumb

    Over the years I have worked numerous dinner meetings for pharmaceutical companies in the Kansas City area. A few years back Morton’s appeared to have a corner on the market when they brought in their own satellite network allowing one speaker to present remotely to all Morton’s in the chain. This was ideal for rolling out new product or having the doc that wrote the book train the locals.
    The money invested in technology would have been better spent on training their staff. My servers had a history of disappearing for extended periods, especially after the entrée was served. Even the GM couldn’t find them. Interesting that this phenomena was never replicated at any of the other restaurants I worked. It is no great surprise that the Morton’s in Kansas City has subsequently closed. I wonder if they ever found all of their employees.

  • http://scottmckain.com Scott McKain

    Wow, Brad…that’s a perfect insight into how technology must be accompanied by the human touch! We can spend out the wazoo on the bells and whistles, so to speak, however if we don’t provide the experience that customers are seeking, it’s all for naught.

    Great comments…thanks so much!

  • http://scottmckain.com Scott McKain

    Jim, that’s a great question…and, honestly, right now the answer is “no.” I WILL, however, continue to dine at the other Morton’s where I have had terrific experiences — which is EVERY other one. They have done an awesome job at every other location. However, if you read Brad Plumb’s post above, you’ll see that wasn’t the case with his experiences in Kansas City.

    So…if you’re in Orlando and don’t travel much…100% of your understanding of Morton’s is based upon the experience you received there! Same is true in KC, as noted by Brad.

    That’s why it is SO important for every organization to emphasize that every customer receive a UCE at every location in the entire company!

    Thanks for a great question and comment!!

  • Tom

    I don’t know why your suprised its all about the market, indy depends on repeat customers and it doesn’t have the traffic that the orlando market has(also the repeat traffic its disney world) your not going to put your best manager in a market like orlando. your going to test to see if they will become your best managers. also, when generating leads and new customer at a rate in orlando you don’t have to be on your a game. you have business by defualt. The mortons name carries the market. I,ve seen a simular patterns in hawaii.next time compare sacramento to indy and see what the results will be.

  • don

    It is amazing BUT true what you have stated. The other day, I eat with my wife at a “Rudy Tuesday” at
    1 PM on a Thursday. We were NOT greeted at the door. We stood by the host stand for no less than
    7 min. before a server came by and showed us a table. By the way, did not say hello or sorry about about our wait. After looking at the menu, we ordered an entree and salad bar. We went to the salad bar and waited for some plates – which was longer than needed to be. The server told us the other plates were dirty. (Some impression) After standing there 5 min. we went back to our table and waited until they finally came out with the plates. They only had three other tables in the restaurant at the time. The salad bar was missing some items. We finished the salad and had to wait another 15 min. beyond for two med. cooked Hamburgers. Then waited without seeing a manager or server come back by to see if everything was good for another 12 min..The hamburgers were totally dark red in the middle. My wife couldn’t eat hers. I can see why they only had three tables for lunch. And YES, we HAVE NOT been back to any “Ruby Tuesday”. Total time at the restaurant 1 hr and 40 min.- unbelievable. I would have left the restaurant, But my wife didn’t want me to say anything. Keeping with their MO, they didn’t ask how the dinning experience was when I paid. And No, I didn’t leave a tip, which is most unusual for me. I emailed their corp. headquarters, and you guessed it, I didn’t hear anything back from them, too.

Previous post:

Next post: