Is Apple losing it?

August 15, 2010 · 6 comments

I’m an Apple fanboy.

But, I’m starting to get worried.

One of the big points I made in “Collapse of Distinction” and “What Customers REALLY Want” is that we hate it when new customers are treated better than loyal ones.

Yet, it is starting to seem as though Apple really doesn’t care how many products you’ve purchased from them in the past…or your level of loyalty to them through the years…it’s all about what’s happening now.

At the Apple Store on Saturday, I was seeking some assistance for the extraordinarily poor performance of my iPhone 4.

It’s simply unacceptable. Dropped calls, for one. While I’m on the phone, all of a sudden music starts playing…or it dials someone else…it’s totally unpredictable.

So, I make an appointment and start talking with the Genius. It’s important to note: He was extraordinarily knowledgable and friendly. This is not a situation of dealing with someone who didn’t care about my problem.

When I talked about dropped calls, he asked if I had ordered the “bumpers” yet. I told him I had, but they wouldn’t be in for about three weeks. He told me they had none in stock, and had absolutely no idea when some would be available.

However, he assured me, they WILL solve the dropped call problem.

(Which, of course, means three more weeks of dropped calls!)

My other situation with the music and unwanted dial-outs? “It’s a software problem,” he said. “I’m talking with lots of people every single day facing the same thing.” (WHAT????)

He assured me Apple was hard at work on a fix — and we should be able to download it before too much longer.

I’m sorry…as an Apple loyalist, that’s pretty hard to swallow.

The phone drops calls — but don’t worry, a fix is coming. The phone dials out to people you aren’t trying to call, or your iTunes music will blare when you least expect it — but don’t worry, a fix is coming.

Isn’t that the kind of “let our customers find our mistakes” and “buy it now, we’ll fix it later” approach that we Mac-heads used to brag were reasons that Microsoft was inferior?

I also had a Time Capsule that had died. I was told I was a couple of months out of warranty — but, they would give me a “deal” on a refurbished model. It was fifty bucks off of a new one.

What happened to, “Mr. McKain, you’ve purchased Mac Plus, Mac SE, Classic, LC, IIx, IIvi, Power Book 170, Duo 210…well, you’ve been loyal for a long time. Let us make this right!”?

Something is starting to go wrong at Apple. Maybe it’s having so much money in the bank…maybe it’s being the “darling” of the media…maybe it’s thinking your products are so fantastic, we can slack off on our loyal customers…they’re going to come back anyhow, right?

Can a company prevent “losing it” when it gets to the top?

I hope so. I think so.

But, I know it requires a recommitment to your core. No matter how big or successful you have become.

Share and Enjoy:
  • Print
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • LinkedIn
  • http://deliverbliss.com Tim Sanchez

    Apple lost some of its luster with the iPhone 4 issues, but I think the better question is, “Where else are you gonna go?” If you had a PC or an Android phone with similar problems, where are you going to go to get answers? Microsoft? Google? Verizon? Sprint? No, because you know you won't get answers.

    Apple is managing extraordinary growth and entering new markets with wild success. There are bound to be some bumps along the way, but fanboys like us will ultimately stick them because we trust they'll make it right. And, quite frankly, where else are you going to get a better experience?

  • http://www.McKainViewpoint.com Scott McKain

    Tim, I can't argue with you…just thought I needed to pose the question.

    I have an Android phone on Sprint, as well — and while it doesn't drop calls and is a great phone, the total user experience just isn't as sleek and polished as the iPhone. (Which indicates how much more we're doing with smartphones these days than just making calls.)

    Although, I do have to say, while it did not used to be the case, Sprint's service just KILLS AT&T these days. They've improved dramatically…

    However…you're right — we can't get a better experience any place else. I just want to send up a warning flare…because I sure don't want that to get lost in this growth in new markets.

    Thanks for — as always — advancing the conversation.

    Scott

  • http://leadchangegroup.com Mike Henry Sr.

    Actually, it may be stock market pressure. You hinted at it but that is a difficult force to resist. Many great companies started protecting themselves and playing prevent defense. You never need to do that until you're in the lead.

  • http://mikecanex.wordpress.com/2010/08/16/is-apple-losing-it-%e2%80%94-scott-mckain-viewpoint/ Is Apple losing it? — Scott McKain Viewpoint « Mike Cane's xBlog

    [...] Is Apple losing it? — Scott McKain Viewpoint. Published [...]

  • http://www.christophevanbael.com Christophe Van Bael

    Excellent post Scott, and an interesting reply, Tim!

    I'm an Apple fan myself. I don't want to know how much I've spent with them in the past because I don't care: their products are great, and their service is exceptional… in my experience. I don't own an iPhone 4 (yet), but reading about all the problems with the iPhone 4 and the customer service/PR disaster that followed the media storm a few weeks ago, I can only conclude that there is something going on with Apple.

    As your rightly argue, Tim, Apple is managing extraordinary growth and entering new markets with wild success. This can never be an excuse for poor customer service, though. Customer service should be a culture (until recently, we all thought it was hard-wired in Apple's DNA), it shouldn't be abandoned because of some unforeseen problems with a new product. Instead, it should thrive in such a situation. I don't like the idea that a company at the top of its segment can get away with poor service because customers can't go anywhere else for similar products and services… This can only lead to loss of trust. I don't know how long us fanboys will stick when our trust declines.

    As you rightly argued in one of your previous posts, Tim, customers' perceptions are determined by the aligment of customer expectations and the performance of a company. With regard to Apple, could it be that Apple has always strived for (near-)perfection, that they have raised customers' expectations accordingly, and that they don't know how to handle (customer service for) a less than perfect product?

    I look forward to hearing your thoughts!

    Christophe.

  • JDM

    Welcome to technology. Did you buy the version 1 iPhone or iPod right when they came out? Did you buy the Blackberry Storm when it came out? Perhaps you purchased the new Windows right when it came out??? This is the world we live in…technology driven world where everyone needs the latest and greatest device on launch day even if they don't have a clue how to use 90% of the features on it and maintain it.

    Beta and focus group testing only goes so far… until you scale completely in mainstream you simply cannot develop a technology product to its fullest. This is why generally within the first 6 months of a tech product or software launch there are a number of updates provided.

    The only difference with the iPhone4 and previous releases is that due to Steve Jobs brilliance and an incredible executive team at Apple…they are re-defining customer satisfaction to a point where every idiot in the world actually expects complete perfection from Apple…I mean COMPLETE perfection. When you are the king of the castle…the critics want to destroy you and thus your flaws are magnified beyond belief. Just so happens Apple became King since their last major release…and here we are!

    If you expect perfection in a new version technology product… don't go stand in line on release day. Wait 6 months and buy then. This is the case with every product…Apple or not.

    I'm pretty sure the Apple user base just increased another % point while I wrote this. If you want some interesting numbers… check out the iPhone4 return rate in comparison to previous iPhones and other top smartphone devices.

Previous post:

Next post: